Mellow Mushroom brings its signature blend of creative stone-baked pizzas, eclectic atmosphere, and laid-back vibes to St. Augustine's Anastasia Island, creating a dining destination that appeals to pizza purists and adventurous eaters alike. Located at 410 Anastasia Boulevard, this popular restaurant sits perfectly positioned to serve residents of Historic Downtown St. Augustine, Saint Augustine Beach, Vilano Beach, and surrounding communities. Part of a beloved regional chain known for allowing each location to develop its own personality while maintaining strict quality standards, the St. Augustine Mellow Mushroom delivers an experience that feels simultaneously familiar and unique, with colorful art installations, quirky decor, and an atmosphere that encourages guests to relax and stay awhile. The Mellow Mushroom philosophy centers on delivering what they call "A Higher Order of Pizza" through commitment to quality ingredients, unique flavor combinations, and traditional stone-baking techniques that create exceptional crust texture and flavor. Unlike many pizza chains that rely on speed and convenience over quality, Mellow takes the time to do things right, starting with their signature spring water crust that provides a distinctive flavor and perfect texture. The dough is made fresh daily, hand-tossed by trained pizza artists, and baked in high-temperature stone ovens that create that ideal combination of crispy exterior and tender interior that defines truly great pizza. The menu at Mellow Mushroom offers both classic pizzas and inventive specialty pies that push flavor boundaries in exciting directions. The build-your-own pizza option gives complete creative control, starting with the classic Mellow crust (available in traditional, thin, or gluten-free for small pizzas), red sauce, and mozzarella cheese. From there, diners can select from an impressive array of premium toppings including specialty meats, fresh vegetables, various cheeses, and unexpected ingredients like banana peppers, sun-dried tomatoes, and even tofu for vegetarian pizzas. The ability to customize half-and-half pizzas means groups can satisfy multiple preferences without ordering multiple pies. Specialty pizzas showcase the creativity and skill that have made Mellow Mushroom famous throughout the Southeast. The Holy Shiitake Pie features shiitake, button, and portobello mushrooms with caramelized onions, mozzarella, and MontAmore cheese, finished with garlic aioli and truffle oil for an earthy, luxurious flavor profile. The Mighty Meaty arrives loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, ham, and bacon for carnivores seeking maximum meat. The Great White delivers sophisticated flavors with an olive oil and garlic base topped with mozzarella, provolone, seasoned ricotta, roasted tomatoes, authentic sheep's milk feta, fresh Roma tomatoes, sweet onions, and chopped fresh basil. The Magical Mystery Tour combines pesto sauce base with button mushrooms, feta, spinach