Collage Restaurant

Collage Restaurant represents the pinnacle of fine dining in St. Augustine, offering an intimate, award-winning culinary experience that has earned national recognition and a devoted following among discerning food enthusiasts. Located just one block off St. George Street in the heart of the historic district, this small 15-table restaurant creates magical evenings through exceptional cuisine, impeccable service, and a warm, inviting atmosphere that makes every guest feel like they are dining at a friend's sophisticated home rather than a commercial establishment. Owners Mike Hyatt and Cindy Stangby created Collage more than a decade ago with a clear vision: to serve the finest fresh local ingredients prepared with international flavor profiles in an intimate setting where every detail matters. Their commitment to excellence has been rewarded with numerous prestigious accolades, including multiple selections as one of the "Top 100 Best Restaurants in America" by OpenTable and recognition as one of "The Best Restaurants in the U.S." for both 2020 and 2021 in Tripadvisor's Travelers' Choice awards. These honors place Collage among the nation's elite dining establishments and cement its reputation as a must-visit destination for food lovers. The moment guests walk through the wooden doors framed by beautiful flowering plants, they enter a world where culinary artistry takes center stage. The intimate dining room features subdued lighting and minimal furnishings that create a refined yet comfortable environment perfect for romantic dinners, special celebrations, and memorable evenings with friends. The small size of the restaurant (just 15 tables) ensures that every guest receives personalized attention and that the kitchen can maintain the highest standards of quality and consistency for every dish that leaves the pass. Collage's menu reflects the eclectic tastes of its owners, focusing on fresh local seafood, premium steaks, lamb, and veal, all prepared with innovative international flavor profiles that showcase the kitchen's creativity and technical expertise. The menu changes seasonally to take advantage of the finest and freshest ingredients available, ensuring that regular guests always discover something new and exciting. Every dish is prepared from scratch with meticulous attention to detail, from the house-made stocks and sauces to the carefully sourced proteins and produce. The seafood selections at Collage are truly exceptional, featuring dishes like Parmesan Brown Sugar and Pecan Crusted Black Grouper served over a local-inspired Minorcan shrimp perloo finished with Cajun cream sauce. The fresh Corvina preparation and the Pan Seared Diver Caught Scallops served over pomme puree with Florida summer corn succotash represent the restaurant's commitment to showcasing both local and premium imported ingredients. The Lobster Stuffed Ravioli with sautéed shrimp in pesto cream sauce, topped with a Maine lobster tail, has become a sign