Lincolnville Historic District

The Lincolnville Historic District stands as one of the most significant and inspiring neighborhoods in American history, representing both the resilience of a community founded by freed slaves after the Civil War and serving as a pivotal battleground in the Civil Rights Movement that changed our nation. Located on the southwest peninsula of St. Augustine, just minutes from the historic downtown core, this 45-50 block neighborhood offers visitors a profound journey through African American history, beautiful Victorian-era architecture, vibrant cultural institutions, and a thriving contemporary community that honors its past while embracing the future. Lincolnville's story begins in 1866 when seven freedmen and women (Peter Sanks, Matilda Papy, Harriet Weedman, Miles Hancock, Israel McKenzie, Aaron DuPont, and Tom Solana) leased land for just $1 per year on what was then the west bank of Maria Sanchez Creek, across from developed St. Augustine. These pioneers established a settlement originally called "Africa" or "Little Africa," creating a community where formerly enslaved people could build new lives, establish businesses, purchase property, and exercise the freedoms they had been denied. After streets were laid out in 1878, the community came to be known as Lincolnville, likely named in honor of President Abraham Lincoln, whose Emancipation Proclamation had begun the journey toward freedom. The area that would become Lincolnville had its own complex earlier history. The land had been home to Indian villages, later became part of colonial plantations including the Dumas plantation "Yalaha" (Seminole word for orange) and "Buena Esperanza" (Spanish for "Good Hope"), both devoted to orange grove cultivation. Even Abraham Lincoln's private secretary, John Hay (who later served as Secretary of State under Theodore Roosevelt), owned a 5-acre orange grove in what would become the northwest corner of modern Lincolnville. This layered history adds to the neighborhood's fascinating character. African Americans trace their presence in St. Augustine back to the city's 16th-century founding, playing integral roles throughout the city's history despite facing increasing restrictions as forced segregation became law in the late 1800s. Lincolnville became the center of African American life in St. Augustine, where residents built churches, schools, and a vibrant business district surrounded by homes displaying the ornate Victorian architecture popular during that era. By 1930, Lincolnville had grown to encompass both the African American community itself and adjacent white residential areas that had developed alongside it, becoming a major part of the city. The neighborhood's golden age came during the segregation era when, paradoxically, the exclusionary conditions that limited African Americans' access to white-owned businesses encouraged the flourishing of black-owned enterprises. By the 1920s, a lively commercial district centered on Washington